UN in the News
Top of Page
US Vetoes Resolution Backing UN Observer Force
(AP)March, 28 2001
ISRAEL REACTS TO THE UN SECURITY COUNCIL VOTE
(Communicated by the Foreign Ministry Spokesperson)
Jerusalem, 28 March 2001
Last night (March 27), the adoption of a one-sided resolution by
the UN Security Council, which would have ignored Palestinian
responsibility for the violence, was prevented. Israel welcomes
Israel wishes to express its appreciation for the American
decision, under the circumstances created in the course of the
Council debate, to exercise its veto and thus to prevent the
adoption of a resolution which would only have had the effect of
aggravating the crisis in our region. Israel also appreciates the
Ukrainian decision not to take part in the vote.
Israel is disappointed at the surprising change in Russia's
position and at the support given by several states to the
initiative proposed in several draft resolutions, which is
completely inconsistent with the principles of the peace process,
and tries to circumvent agreements and understandings already
reached through direct contact between the parties.
It is ironic that the members of the Security Council put forward
an unbalanced proposal regarding the protection of Palestinian
civilians precisely at this time, when Israeli citizens, victims
of Palestinian terrorism, are being killed and injured.
Israel wishes to stress again, irrespective of the debate and the
decision taken by the Security Council, the need to put an
immediate stop to the acts of violence and terrorism being
conducted against Israel and its citizens, among them youngsters
In its first U.N. veto since 1997, the United States heeded a call from Israel and killed a resolution backing a U.N. observer force to help protect Palestinians.
Palestinians reacted with disgust Tuesday to the first U.S. veto in four years, saying it reflected badly on the Bush administration.
"This is unfortunate, especially in the light of the fact that this is a new administration and we were hoping for this administration to demonstrate a more balanced position," said Palestinian representative Nasser Al-Kidwa.
After five days of around-the-clock negotiations, the Palestinians had secured the nine votes they needed to pass the measure in the 15-member U.N. Security Council. The four European council members - Britain, France, Norway andIreland - abstained, and Ukraine didn't case a vote.
Russia provided the necessary ninth vote after switching sides from December, when it abstained along with the United States on a similar measure calling for observer force that failed for lack of votes.
Relations between the United States and Russia have been clouded in recent weeks by tit-for-tat expulsions of diplomats over espionage allegations.
Only the five permanent council members - the United States, Russia, China, France and Britain - can issue vetoes, but they try to be sparing with them, in part bcause vetoes anger less powerful members who are esentful that five countries can essentially dictate U.N. policy.
The United States had tried to avoid using its veto, worried that it would inflame passions in the West Bank and Gaza and infuriate Arab nations. The United States has only vetoed five resolutions since May 1990, all dealing with the Mideast dispute and the last coming in 1997 to quash a demand that Israel stop building a settlement in eastern Jerusalem.
"The United States casts this vote with great regret," said acting U.S. Ambassador James Cunningham.
"It should not have been necessary, and this draft should not have been put to a vote."
Earlier Tuesday, negotiators had said they were close to a compromise with the Americans on a watered-down resolution calling for the immediate end to six months of clashes between Israel and the Palestinians that have left more than 400 people dead.
The compromise text made no mention of a U.N. observer force to protect Palestinian civilians. Instead, it called on Secretary-General Kofi Annan to consult with the parties "on setting up a protection mechanism, to contribute to the protection of Palestinian civilians."
But with word late Tuesday from Washington that it wasn't prepared to sign off on even that text, the Palestinians' allies in the council resurrected their call for UN observers and put their own resolution to a vote.
The Palestinians were eager for a result from the council before a summit of Arab leaders in the Jordanian capital, Amman, concludes Wednesday.
Israel had vehemently opposed sending a U.N. observer force and wanted direct talks with the Palestinians instead.
After the vote, Israel's U.N. ambassador Yehuda Lancry cited a series of recent attacks, including the bombings and the shooting death of a 10-month-old Israeli girl, as reasons for why the "one-sided" resolution was rightly vetoed.
"The reality of the past 24 hours has gruesomely reminded us that the double-edged sword of this conflict cuts both ways," he said.
An hour after the vote, an apparent suicide bombing at a gas station in central Israel killed three people this morning, local officials said.
The vetoed Palestinian resolution instructed Annan to consult with the parties and report back to the Security Council. The resolution "expresses the readiness of the Council to act upon receipt of the report to set up an appropriate mechanism to protect Palestinian civilians, including through the establishment of a United Nations observer force."
Cunningham said the United States believed that strategy was not feasible without an agreement between Israel and the Palestinians.
"The United States opposed this resolution because it is unbalanced and unworkable, and hence unwise," he said.
"It is more responsive to political favor than political reality."
Danish Foreign Minister Mogens Lykketoft blasted Israel in a newspaper interview published yesterday, saying that the EU should institute economic sanctions against Israel because of its settlement policy.