Israel Report

December 2002         

Is a Palestinian State a Foregone Conclusion?

by Ruth Matar - December 29, 2002
Is a Palestinian state within Israel a foregone conclusion?

Certainly not, even though our government and our media want us to believe that it is, and try hard to suppress any opposition to the creation of such a state. Evidence for such suppression came in the form of two utterly horrendous undemocratic events that occurred this past week in Israel.

Israeli police and Communications Ministry personnel raided the ship from which Arutz-Sheva Israel National Radio broadcasts at 1pm on December 24, halting the station's signal for over an hour. The police photographed equipment and workers, but confiscated nothing. The ship's captain was warned not to resume transmission of the broadcasts. The raid began ended at approximately 2:15pm. The Arutz-Sheva management noted that this was the first time in the history of Israeli off-shore broadcasting — including Abie Natan's Voice of Peace ship, and fifteen years of Arutz-Sheva broadcasts — that the police have ever made such a raid. The radio station said that not even under the governments of Yitzhak Rabin, Shimon Peres, or Ehud Barak were police ever sent to raid a ship broadcasting from outside Israel’s territorial waters. Arutz-Sheva broadcasts from those waters in order to circumvent legislation that prohibits privately-owned radio stations from airing nationwide. Although a law duly passed by the Knesset granted Arutz-Sheva a broadcasting license, it was recently nullified by the Supreme Court, due to a petition from the Left. Arutz-Sheva is the only radio voice opposing the establishment of a Palestinian state.

National Union party leader MK Avigdor Lieberman said that the raid is nothing more than political scheming, based on election-campaign considerations, and as revenge for Arutz-Sheva's clear policy against a Palestinian state. MK Tzvi Hendel said that this is a case of "political persecution on the eve of elections," and demanded that Communications Minister Rivlin open an immediate investigation into how this occurred. MK Uri Ariel said that the raid is an attempt to "shut mouths." MK Benny Elon said that the authority of the Supreme Court — which put a freeze on a duly-passed Knesset law legalizing Arutz-Sheva – must be curtailed "in order to prevent it from making a mockery of Israel's democracy."

The second item was Moshe Feiglin’s disqualification as a Likud candidate by the Election Committee, which cited his past conviction for "sedition". The conviction was due to a series of non-violent protests organized by Moshe Feiglin against the Oslo process. A number of the non-violent protests included the temporary blocking of roads. It is noteworthy that while Feiglin and others associated with the handful of temporary road-blocking incidents in protest of Oslo were prosecuted for their action, to this day MK (Am Echad) Amir Peretz has never been charged for what may reach billions of dollars of damage he is responsible for due to illegal strike and protest activity, which the Histadrut has carried out over the years under his direction. While Feiglin closed a few crossroads down for a few minutes, Peretz's group has illegally closed down major highways for hours at a time — in one action even physically blocking the runways at Ben Gurion Airport. Besides illegally blocking roads, over the years Peretz's organization has violated orders to return to work, and taken other illegal activity that has cost the Israeli public and economy dearly. According to MK Michael Kleiner, banning Feiglin is like banning Martin Luther King and Mahatma Gandhi for non-violent disobedience to free the Blacks and the Asian Indians.

However, most disturbing of recent events is the metamorphosis of Ariel Sharon. What has happened to Sharon? What brought about this change? Here is a paragraph from his autobiography, Warrior, published in 1989 (page 402):

“When Begin brought the autonomy plan to the government, many in his Herut (Likud) Party found it insupportable, a betrayal by Begin of the Jewish claim to Eretz Israel. My own reaction was that the plan was loaded with danger. It could easily, I said, become a Balfour Declaration for the Palestinians and might well lead to a second Palestinian state (in addition to Jordan), something no Israeli with any regard for the country's safety could agree to.”

On the other hand, a recent article that appeared in the newspaper Maariv about a blowout that Sharon had with a very popular Likud Knesset member, Zahi Hanegbi, is indicative of the new Sharon. Zahi Hanegbi ranks third on the Likud list, preceded only by Sharon and Netanyahu. The first ten Likud members on the list, in fact, are all against a Palestinian state, with one exception — Ariel Sharon. At the said meeting Sharon demanded that his ministers in the Likud show a united front and endorse the idea of a Palestinian state. The Maariv article quotes Sharon as saying:

“We should all give the same message; i.e., that Israel would be willing to give the Palestinians a state, that not the Turks, not the British, not the Egyptians, and not the Jordanians agreed to give them.”

When the shocked Likud ministers tried to tell Sharon that favoring the creation of a Palestinian state was against the Likud platform, against Likud party bylaws, and against the decision of the Likud Central Committee, Sharon told them to shut up, clearly saying that he will not allow people in his government who oppose him on the issue of a Palestinian state.

It is extraordinary that we allow Ariel Sharon to become a virtual dictator. Caroline B. Glick, Deputy Managing Editor of the Jerusalem Post indirectly answered a question I posed in the past - "Are the People Allowed to Decide?":

“The same people who foisted upon us the Oslo process, the same people who brought us Arafat, and the murder of one thousand Israelis since 1994 still determine what we can and cannot say, and what we can or cannot discuss. Sharon himself said in an interview in September of this year, before Rosh HaShana, that the Oslo agreements are dead. And now in December, he says that Israel must abide by all the concessions that the Oslo government made from 1993 to 2000 to Yasser Arafat. To object to the establishment of Palestine in Judea, Samaria and Gaza is illegitimate, even though it has been proven beyond any shred of reasonable doubt that such a state will in fact be dangerous and suicidal to the State of Israel.”

Dr. Aaron Lerner, a recent guest on my radio program, also feels that the democratic process in Israel is not working. In May of this year, the Likud Central Committee voted overwhelmingly against a Palestinian state. Sharon walked out in a huff, and said that he will do what he wants. The rank and file of Likud people are opposed to a Palestinian state. Nonetheless, there is a massive campaign to convince the public that a Palestinian state is a foregone conclusion. Yet, the opposite is shown by the polls that ask any kind of detailed questions. For instance, the Steimetz Center of Tel Aviv University found in an opinion survey conducted two weeks ago that less than a third of Israeli Jews polled would agree to the Palestinians having sovereignty over Arab neighborhoods in East Jerusalem.

Not always did Ariel Sharon consider the Women in Green as being in opposition to his policies and, therefore, needing at all costs to have outlets for their voices silenced. After 1993, Ariel Sharon and the Women in Green were both fighting against the Oslo Accords and against the creation of a Palestinian state. When Sharon was elected Prime Minister, he thanked Women in Green for their part in achieving success for the national camp. The following is the text of a letter signed by Ariel Sharon, dated February 2001, which was published in our Purim journal of that year:

“Dear Ruth and Nadia,

“Just as in the past, also this year I have the pleasure and honor to congratulate you and all the Women in Green, on the occasion of this festive Purim event which takes place on the eve of the Fast of Esther in Jerusalem. Following my recent election as Prime Minister, I send you very special greetings from our Eternal Capital, Jerusalem, and my deep thanks for your part in achieving success for the national camp.

“The election victory is just the beginning of our uphill struggle for our legitimate rights for Eretz Israel and a United Jerusalem. I acknowledge your praiseworthy efforts and am sure you will continue to be in the forefront of this struggle to achieve security for our people and peace for generations to come, as you proudly carry the flag for the revival of Zionism.

“In the days of trial before us, you are an example of the saying 'A woman of valor, who will find…'

“Your steadfastness awakens feelings of pride in my heart and I have hope that together we will succeed, in spite of all the difficulties facing us in achieving our dreams and aspirations.

“Warmest greetings from our Eternal Capital of Israel, Jerusalem, and the Jewish People.

“Be strong and of good courage,

“Ariel Sharon, Prime Minister”

It is with great sadness that the Women in Green think back on the days when we considered Ariel Sharon our hero. We are no longer together in the struggle for, as Sharon wrote to us, “the legitimate rights of Eretz Israel and a United Jerusalem.” Sharon may have abandoned these goals for what he thinks is pragmatic reasons, or because of unbearable pressures from the United States. Maybe his attitude now goes under the heading of "facing reality." Rather than falling in line with such defeatist thinking, we should read what Hashem said to Joshua after Moses' death: “Be strong and courageous, for it is you who will cause this people to inherit the land that I have sworn to their fathers to give them.” (Joshua 1:6)

To all our friends, Jews and Christians, who believe in the Bible: this should be an encouragement for all of us. We may have many enemies, but with G-d's help we will fight together to ensure Israel's survival. We need to be passionate; in these crucial times we cannot afford to be complacent. The struggle for Israel's survival should occupy our thoughts - morning, noon and night. Continually write, fax, email and telephone your senators, your representatives and President George W. Bush that the creation of a Palestinian terrorist state is a danger, not only for Israel, but for all of Western Judeo-Christian civilization.

Ruth Matar is co-chairwoman of the grass-roots activist organization Women for Israel's Tomorrow (Women in Green). This article was adapted from the Women in Green radio program on Arutz Sheva - Israel National Radio, which can be heard on demand at IsraelNationalNews.com.

©2002 - IsraelNationalNews.com


Send  To A FriendSend To A Friend       Return to Israel Report - December 2002       HOME
Jerusalem !
Recommended Links
 
 
Powered By:NuvioTemplates.com