Pursuing a personal dream, Pope John Paul II arrived in Israel in
late March for his historic pilgrimage to the Holy Land. This first-ever
official papal visit to Israel was welcomed by most - though not all -
Israelis as a potent symbol of the significant changes that have taken
place in Catholic-Jewish relations during his 22-year pontificate.
Although the Vatican billed it as a spiritual journey to trace "the
history of salvation," many Israelis hoped John Paul would use it
to build on his positive record towards the Jewish people. Meanwhile,
the Palestinians were determined to score a few points of their own,
forcing the ailing 79-year-old pontiff to navigate a political minefield
at a crucial juncture in peace talks over the biblical heartland of
Israel and the city of Jerusalem.
The journey began on March 20 in Jordan – the first stop in his
six-day tour of the Holy Land. Moving slowly but with a sense of
purpose, John Paul deplaned in Amman to a royal welcome, toured the
biblical sites of Mount Nebo, the traditional site where Moses looked
over into the Promised Land, and the newly-proclaimed site of
Bethany-beyond-the-Jordan, which has been quickly developed and promoted
as the place where Jesus was baptized. He also held a stadium Mass
attended by 40,000 – including hundreds of Iraqi Christians living as
refugees in eastern Jordan. Some wanted Vatican assistance to lift UN
sanctions on their country; others sought asylum in the West.
That evening, the Pope’s short, low flight to Ben-Gurion Airport
hit turbulence, providing a foretaste of things to come in Israel. The
official visit began well, with a red-carpet welcome on a brisk, rainy
evening. After the frail Pontiff kissed a bowl of Israeli soil, Prime
Minister Ehud Barak said, "Welcome to the Holy Land." The
colorful reception stood in stark contrast to the last papal visit to
Israel in 1964, when Pope Paul VI snubbed Israeli leaders in Jerusalem
and never publicly uttered the name of the state of Israel. But Pope
John Paul II - a former Polish priest who witnessed the horrors of the
Holocaust first-hand - has forged an unprecedented papal record of
goodwill towards the Jewish people and in 1994 oversaw the Vatican’s
recognition of the state of Israel (though not Jerusalem as its
capital). Thus he was received warmly by Israeli officials as a genuine
friend of the Jews.
The next day was set aside for a visit to the Palestinian-ruled
Bethlehem area, where the Pope sounded a decidedly pro-Palestinian note
of the sort which the Vatican had assured was not on the agenda.
Palestinian Authority chairman Yasser Arafat welcomed him with a
military parade, the Palestinian anthem and other trappings of
statehood. John Paul played along, kissing a bowl of Palestinian earth
and adopting rhetoric interpreted by the Palestinians as a powerful
endorsement of their hopes for independence. John Paul had already
recognized Palestinian national rights back in 1984. In his remarks in
Bethlehem, the Pope said: "No one can ignore how much the
Palestinian people have had to suffer in recent decades. Your torment is
before the eyes of the world. And it has gone on too long... The Holy
See has always recognized that the Palestinian people have a natural
right to a homeland," the Pope declared.
The Pope then conducted an open-air Mass on Manger Square, outside
the Church of the Nativity, attended by five thousand – far less than
the 20,000 predicted. As he finished his homily with an "Amen"
around noon, the Muslim call to prayer suddenly blared from the
loudspeakers of an imposing grand mosque on Manger Square.
Subsequently, the Pope paid a one-hour visit to the nearby Dheisheh
refugee camp, where Palestinians greeted him with photographic exhibits
of the refugees’ plight. They were hoping he would expressly endorse
the right of return, and again the pontiff did not disappoint, speaking
of the "sad memory of what you were forced to leave behind."
The Vatican had already miffed Israeli leaders by suggesting they were
balancing a visit to Yad Vashem with the tour of the refugee camp. The
Palestinians were obviously elated with John Paul’s message, although
a violent stone-throwing melee erupted between camp youth and PA police
just after he left.
If the stop in Bethlehem was designed as the "Palestinian
leg" of the Pope’s journey, the next day was designed to showcase
the new Vatican-Israel relationship. John Paul first made a call on
Israel’s two chief rabbis at the Great Synagogue in western Jerusalem,
and then visited President Ezer Weizman at his official residence. Then,
continuing through the streets of Jerusalem, the Pope made his way to
what many considered the focal point of his visit, Yad Vashem – the
nation’s revered memorial to the Jewish martyrs and Gentile rescuers
of the Holocaust.
Although in 1965 the Roman Catholic Church - confronted with the
reality of a Jewish state in the Land of Israel – rescinded its
doctrine that God had cursed the Jews to eternal wandering for killing
Christ, efforts to mend fences with the Jewish people remained slow and
begrudging until Pope John Paul II took office. He soon became the first
pope to declare anti-Semitism a sin against God; to visit a synagogue;
to affirm the right of Jews to return to their ancient homeland; and to
confirm the enduring nature of God’s covenants with the "elder
brothers" of Christianity.
Yet a series of polls just before his visit indicated few Israelis
were aware of these developments. And although the Vatican had
apologized on over three dozen occasions for the hateful actions of
individual "sons and daughters of the Church" against Jews,
many hoped that at Yad Vashem, this remarkable Pope would express regret
for the Catholic Church’s collective responsibility for sowing the
seeds of the Holocaust and remaining silent at its depths. Indeed, the
Vatican has yet to address the historical facts that the Nazis – in
passing the racist Nürnberg laws, forcing Jews to wear yellow stars and
placing them in ghettos – were simply emulating actions which
originated within the Catholic Church. Sadly, there exists an
irrefutable connection between centuries of anti-Semitic Catholic
teachings and the prevailing mindset in wartime Europe which allowed
Hitler to single out the Jews for annihilation.
Thus, all eyes were focused on the moment when the ailing John Paul
II toured Yad Vashem to pay homage to the over six million Jewish
victims of the Shoah. There, the Pope made a show of empathy for Jewish
suffering that will be hard for many Israelis to forget, especially when
he warmly consoled a weeping Holocaust survivor who claimed he had once
saved her life. But the Jewish memory of this event will be mixed with
disappointment over the Pope’s cautious apologetic message, as he
broke no new ground and actually fell short of past statements.
After laying a wreath on a slab where the ashes of Jews from six
extermination camps are buried, the Pope leaned on his cane while
silently staring down for half a minute at the eternal flame flickering
in the dim, cool Hall of Remembrance - a place designed to leave one
uncomfortable. Finally addressing the gathering, he stated: "As
bishop of Rome and successor of the Apostle Peter, I assure the Jewish
people that the Catholic Church, motivated by the Gospel law of truth
and love and by no political considerations, is deeply saddened by the
hatred, acts of persecution, and displays of anti-Semitism directed
against the Jews by Christians at any time and in any place."
PM Barak – who recalled that his own grandparents from Warsaw were
sent to their deaths in Treblinka – accepted the Pope’s pleas and
hailed his efforts in healing Christian-Jewish relations. But he also
made a veiled reference to the silence of Pope Pius XII during the
Holocaust, noting that when the Jews "were led from all over
Christian Europe to the crematoria and the gas chambers, it seemed that
no longer could one place any hope in God or man... And the silence was
not only from the heavens."
Nonetheless, the Vatican sees the Church as a victim of Nazi
persecution as well, and believes its recent words of contrition are
more than sufficient. Ultimately, it was more interested in protecting
the self-image of the Catholic Church and Pius XII - who is up for
beatification.
Later that day, the Pope hosted Jewish and Muslim leaders for an
interfaith gathering that turned sour when Ashkenazi Chief Rabbi Yisrael
Lau was heckled by Palestinian guests. A top PA sheikh stoked passions
further by rattling off a list of grievances committed by "the
occupier," who was "strangling Jerusalem and oppressing its
residents." He charged Israel with a long record of
"genocide," and later stormed out of the gathering before the
ceremonial planting of an olive tree.
The next morning, the papal tour moved on to a rainy Galilee, where
the skies parted on up to 100,000 hearty Catholic faithful –
predominantly youth – gathered to share in an outdoor Mass near the
traditional site of the Sermon on the Mount. On Shabbat, the Pope
conducted a private Mass at the Basilica of the Annunciationin Nazareth
– where radical Muslims grudgingly kept a low profile at the hotly
disputed site where they want to build a provocative grand mosque.
Pope John Paul II ended his landmark pilgrimage on a Sunday by
visiting the most revered, and contested, sites in the Old City of
Jerusalem. While the pontiff’s dramatic moment at the Western Wall
capped his over-all positive message towards the Jews and his Mass at
the Holy Sepulchre highlighted his concerns for Christian unity, his
encounter with Muslims on the Temple Mount turned into another arduous
test in divine grace.
On the Temple Mount, the Pope was greeted by Palestinian
schoolchildren waving Palestinian flags and chanting slogans under a sea
of balloons in nationalist colors. Accompanied by PLO official Faisal
Husseini, the acid-tongued Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, Sheikh Ekrima Sabri
- a figure appointed by Arafat - called on John Paul II "to end the
Israeli occupation of Jerusalem." Israeli and Vatican officials
were already approaching the meeting with a note of dread, especially
after the Mufti charged the day before that Israel has exaggerated the
figure of six million Jews murdered in the Holocaust to gain
international support. "It’s not my problem," Sabri told the
AP. "Muslims didn’t do anything on this issue. It’s the
doing of Hitler who hated the Jews," he added. [Muslims indeed were
deeply involved with Hitler’s attempts to exterminate the Jews; please
see this month’s Backgrounder. Ed.]
"Six million? It was a lot less," Sabri repeated for an
Italian newspaper. "It’s not my fault if Hitler hated the Jews.
Anyway, they hate them just about everywhere." With the media
spotlight suddenly focused on him, the Mufti also suggested to Reuters
that Israel uses the Holocaust "for political gain and
blackmail."
Put on the spot again, John Paul II decided to stay above the fray,
responding that "Jerusalem has always been revered by Jews,
Christians and Muslims." The pontiff was accompanied by Israeli
security to the Mount and did not actually enter either the Dome of the
Rock or al-Aqsa mosque. Surprisingly, immediately after the Pope
left, Husseini was stoned by dozens of Muslim youths, apparently riled
by rumors he was offering the Vatican the symbolic keys to Jerusalem and
al-Aqsa.
The Pope then made his way to the Western Wall, where he followed
Jewish tradition by placing a written prayer in a crevice. After his
visit to the Kotel, the Pope entered the Church of the Holy Sepulchre
for a special Mass for some 200 invited guests and clergy from sects who
often clash for control over every inch of the Church. He later made an
unscheduled return to the Church for private prayer as his last act
before departing the Holy Land.
"God of our fathers, You
chose Abraham and his descendants to bring Your Name to the Nations. We
are deeply saddened by the behavior of those who in the course of
history have caused these children of Yours to suffer, and asking Your
forgiveness we wish to commit ourselves to genuine brotherhood with the
people of the Covenant." The text of the short typed prayer with official seal placed by Pope
John Paul II in a crevice of the Western Wall. |